Penelope Cigar Sessions Chapter 2 Review: Wheel Horse Cigar Blend, Joseph Magnus Cigar Blend | What Is Cigar Batch Whiskey?
Charlie and Sean review three cigar batch whiskeys: Penelope Cigar Sessions: Chapter 02, Wheel Horse Cigar Blend Bourbon, and Joseph Magnus Cigar Blend Bourbon.
What is cigar batch whiskey? There's no legal definition, so the term means whatever the blender decides it means, and it usually signals a cask-finished whiskey built to stand up to tobacco. We tasted all three on their own and with pipe tobacco. Does a cigar batch need a finish, and is it better with a smoke or without one?
Penelope Cigar Sessions: Chapter 02
A 6-year, 117.4-proof American whiskey blend with no cask finish, developed with Alec Bradley Cigars. It’s sweet and grainy, like a bowl of Rice Krispies and Corn Pops.
Wheel Horse Cigar Blend Bourbon
A 5-year straight bourbon at 101 proof, finished in port, Cognac, sherry, and Armagnac casks. It opens with a buttery nose, then mulled wine, brown sugar, apple, and red fruit.
Joseph Magnus Cigar Blend Bourbon
A straight bourbon from Jos. A. Magnus & Co., developed by master blender Nancy Fraley. It blends 11- and 18-year bourbons finished in Armagnac, sherry, and Cognac casks; we poured Batch 349 at 113 proof. The nose is quiet, but the palate is rich and long, and it tastes older than its age. The barrel influence is “whispering rather than shouting at you.”
Follow 2 Guys 3 Pours so you never miss a new episode every Wednesday.
Transcript
Charlie
::Welcome back to the Two Guys Three Pours Bourbon podcast. I'm Charlie.
Sean
::I'm Sean.
Charlie
::And today we are talking cigar batch whiskey.
Sean
::Yes, we are, Charles. Lead us is cigar batch whiskey.
Charlie
::Well, it's a fiction, Sean. Everything you think you know about cigar batches is incorrect. No. No. So it's, it doesn't have cigar whiskey, cigar batch, cigar session, cigar blend.
It's not a legal term. Like bottle is.
Sean
::Not correct.
Charlie
::Right. So you, it is up to interpretation as to what that means.
Comes down to your, your blenders, your distillers to determine this is a cigar batch for one reason or another. We'll get into a little bit of the details as we go on.
Sean
::So you're saying there's no federal guidelines. No,
Charlie
::There's nothing.
Sean
::They're at will. They could do as they please.
Charlie
::If you determine that a rye whiskey finished in Nerandra casks is a cigar batch.
Sean
::Sure,
Charlie
::Sure. You can do it, bud. That goes against type a little bit. We'll talk about that.
But the floor three bottles that we have in front of us today, we have the Penelope Cigar Sessions, Chapter 2, which is the newest.
Sean
::The newest Y.
Charlie
::To come out. That's going to be our first pour. Second pour, Wheel Horse cigar blend.
Sean
::Horse.
Charlie
::Love some Wheel Horse.
Sean
::Yes. And.
Charlie
::Then our third bottle. This is the OG cigar blend. The Joseph Magnus.
Sean
::And indeed. So that those may. Those who know cigar batches will say this is the OG.
Charlie
::Oh, it is.
Sean
::Of the cigar batches.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::So I like to see that we have an OG and then we have kind of a middle of the road. Sure. Of a low. What others would say as a lower tier. Right. From Wheel Horse. And I'm expecting big things from Wheel Horse.
Charlie
::Absolutely honest.
Sean
::With.
Charlie
::You. Because the cask strength was great.
Sean
::They, they have done. Listen, if you never had Wheel Horse and the cask strength. Right. That's like a, it's like a mini Stagg. Right.
Charlie
::Junior.
Sean
::Junior for 40 bucks. Delicious, right? Absolutely. So Wheel Horse.
Charlie
::Cigar blend.
Sean
::High expectations for Wheel Horse.
Charlie
::So let's start with the Penelope. The Cigar Sessions. This is chapter two. So originally I wanted to include chapter one.
Sean
::Yes. But.
Charlie
::This is. This just came out.
Sean
::This just came out. I think it's fitting for other people to know about it, what we think about it.
Charlie
::Right. This is 117 proof mash bill, 69 corn, 19% rye, 12% malted barley. It's a six year. And that is a derived mash bill because it's a, it's a blend.
This is not a bourbon. Right.
Sean
::Did you Say the proof point that. Yes.
Charlie
::117. And this was 80 bucks.
Sean
::80 bucks.
Charlie
::So the. The first one was pretty good. Now what we'll see is most of these cigar whiskeys. There's some sort of finish.
Sean
::Yes. There.
Charlie
::Penelope.
Sean
::There's nothing.
Charlie
::There's no finish. Session one or session two? Chapter one. Chapter two. There is no finish on either one of them. Exactly. Who they got together, I don't remember.
But Penelope did essentially put together a steering committee of sorts.
Sean
::Yes.
Charlie
::Where folks from cigar manufacturers.
Sean
::There was a panel of people that came around that they're like these blends or this style is.
Charlie
::What.
Sean
::This works best.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::We had this with a pipe. You had this with the.
Charlie
::Sure, I had this one. I had the other one. One thing to note before we get too far into these.
Sean
::Yeah.
Charlie
::All of these we've had with pipes. With pipe tobacco. Right. We talk a little bit more about that. Let's get our first impression of the Penelope.
Sean
::Yeah.
Charlie
::Looks good in the glass. Looks.
Sean
::Good in the glass. It's fine. The bottle's really nice.
Charlie
::Nose. I'm not getting much of anything.
Sean
::Much of anything, to be honest with you. It's very stagnant. I get some sweet oak in the back there. Barely, though. Barely. It's. I.
Charlie
::Get that cereal box cardboardy note again,
Sean
::Lot more. So ethanol. It's not like.
Charlie
::Alcohol.
Sean
::Yeah, More alcohol.
Charlie
::To me. It's.
Sean
::Very light.
Charlie
::It's like if you took. You know when you get the little cereal boxes. Yeah. That's what's open. You pour right into them little baby cereal boxes. If you dump the cereal.
Sean
::Little Rice Krispie treats. Yeah.
Charlie
::It was like Rice Krispies. That's the nose I'm getting. Okay, take a little sip.
Sean
::It's grainy. Grainy.
Charlie
::Yeah, it's.
Sean
::Grainy. Yeah. Take a little sip there.
Charlie
::See our first impression?
Sean
::Sure.
Charlie
::Yeah.
Sean
::It's sweeter.
Charlie
::Sweeter than it smells.
Sean
::Sweeter than it smells up front. I'm getting almost like a. Again going like towards like a sweet tea or sweet corn. A little bit. It's more corny. Yeah.
Charlie
::Yeah. Corn Pops.
Sean
::Corn.
Charlie
::Very cereal. Like, it.
Sean
::Is very serious. I can see why it's. It's sweeter on the palate. So I could see why this would go well with the cigar. I know we did.
Charlie
::Yeah.
Sean
::So personally, I like aromatics.
Charlie
::Sure.
Sean
::I like aromatic tobacco. So high cherry or like a good acid cigar.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::I think the two Sweet. Sweet may not go well with each other.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::I know you're a Virginia guy.
Charlie
::Yeah. I. So I do like now, especially it's starting to cool down. Yeah. I do like an aromatic.
I like tobacco that's a little bit more complex, a little bit smoky, like something with a lot of Latakia in it, like a English blend. But the Cigar Sessions, the first one, chapter one of the Cigar Sessions, to me, it did a really good job in cutting through and.
And pairing with whatever I was smoking, whatever kind of tobacco it was. Chapter two,
Sean
::Little.
Charlie
::Different. It's. It kind of separates itself. Right, Right. If that's what you're looking for. I don't. I don't know. Maybe.
Sean
::But there was a reason why they did something completely different.
Charlie
::Sure.
Sean
::So again, it's all subjective in nature, but yeah, I think it's fine sipping on its.
Charlie
::Own. So what about the taste, though? Are you getting more to me that. That cereal? Cereal box?
Sean
::Yeah. I mean, I gave it a one on the nose, to be honest. I think there's really not much. Yeah. There.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::Again, the cereal box, but not as sweet.
Charlie
::Yeah, yeah. I think it's.
Sean
::There's a little sweet letter way far back there somewhere.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::But it's alcohol. It's grainy.
Charlie
::Yeah, yeah. What about just like your. Your first imp? Like, is this what you think a cigar batch is like? Right, okay. And we'll get into why. But.
Sean
::I think a cigar batch, I see a lot of finishes. Right.
Charlie
::Many.
Sean
::Different finishes. There's a lot more complexity to it. This is very basic to me, and some may, you know, object to that, and that's fine.
I'm used to a little more complexity of different finishes. Sure. So I like how we have something with no finishes and we have two with three finishes, and then we have another one. Four finishes. Four finishes.
But I think it's a fine sipper.
Charlie
::Sure. Well, yeah. So on its own, as just the whiskey. Pretend it's not a cigar batch.
Sean
::No. I'm like,
Charlie
::What do you think?
Sean
::It's fine.
Charlie
::I.
Sean
::Think it's fine. On the palate. I gave it a two.
Charlie
::Two. I gave it a two as well. I gave.
Sean
::It a two on the palate. It's sweet. Like you said. Corn Pops get that cardboardy. It's a little grainy.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::But again, when we had it with a pipe, it was okay.
Charlie
::Sure, sure. And. And that's the thing. That's the. The combination that. The thing I'm unsure of with something like this more than the other two.
And I'm just gonna float it out there.
Sean
::Go for it.
Charlie
::The. When you are having a pipe. Right. The emphasis is on the tobacco because that's all There is.
When you're having a cigar, you have your tobacco and then you also have your cigar leaf.
Sean
::Correct.
Charlie
::Right. One of the reasons why I prefer a pipe over a cigar is. Is because I don't necessarily like too much of that earthy.
Sean
::Okay.
Charlie
::You know, really strong even for a light cigar.
Sean
::Right.
Charlie
::It doesn't do it for me. So I am wondering, though, if we took some, like, Diesels. The Flatheads. Yeah, the.
Sean
::Flatheads, yeah.
Charlie
::Like, does that dramatically. Like a more heavy.
Sean
::Lore. Like, heavy body. Right.
Charlie
::Does that dramatically change the experience?
Sean
::Part two.
Charlie
::Right. We have to try.
Sean
::I agree.
Charlie
::Absolutely. Have to try it. So the.
Sean
::Nose actually opened up a little. It.
Charlie
::Does. It's.
Sean
::Sweeter. Almost giving sweet corn flake. Yeah, a little bit now.
Charlie
::Yeah. It's very cereal.
Sean
::Yeah, it's very cereal.
Charlie
::Very cereal. Morning cereal. I think it's still a one for me on the nose.
Sean
::I agree.
Charlie
::Two in the palate's good finish. I'm giving it nothing for the finish. And the reason is the only thing I get on the finish.
Sean
::One note.
Charlie
::But even still, it's just a little bit of burn.
Sean
::Yeah.
Charlie
::Right. My mouth is coated, but I have a really tough time giving it. Like, it's Even now when we're talking. It's not doing anything. No, it's not.
Sean
::Doing much. But again, is that what it's supposed to do?
Charlie
::Does it clear the.
Sean
::Does it clear your palate.
Charlie
::Yeah.
Sean
::For something else, or does it. That's right. When I find out.
Charlie
::And I think, like I said, in comparison to the. The first chapter. I definitely prefer the first chapter.
Sean
::I'm not a big smoker.
Charlie
::Right. When.
Sean
::I had the pipes, we did that together because you got me into pipes. It's much more. It's different. It's ritualistic. It's. Right. You're. You're sitting back and relaxing. You're being more. We're.
Charlie
::Not doing it for the nicotine fix. It's a mindful. It's a.
Sean
::Mindful thing.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::And so when we did. The first batch was pretty good.
Charlie
::Pretty good. Right.
Sean
::Second batch was okay.
Charlie
::Right. And. And the other difference, I will say, we're talking about Cigar Sessions, chapter two here. Chapter one. I didn't really like it on its own.
Sean
::Okay.
Charlie
::It was. It was okay with something. It was pretty good. This, I think, is better on its.
Sean
::Own than with a.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::And my. Yeah.
Charlie
::Little bit of a marshmallow note going on here. The finish, though, it's. It's just not there. I got the residual heat.
Sean
::I get the residual heat. I get some of that corn flake. A little bit of cardboard there. I gave it a one on the finish. Gave.
Charlie
::A one on the finish.
Sean
::It's not. I think it's a little more. It kind of lingers for a little bit, but it's giving me sweetness on the back end there. So I give it a one.
Charlie
::I'm going to rinse out and take one more sip. Are you getting any additional notes on the finish?
Sean
::No, it's more that. Like that little sweet. Sweet corn.
Charlie
::More of what you got on the palate.
Sean
::Yeah, that's pretty much it.
Charlie
::Yeah.
Sean
::Sweet on the back. It's okay.
Charlie
::I'm okay. Going up to.
Sean
::Level one is okay. I think it's appropriate. Would I buy it again? I'm asking you. Yeah, would you buy it.
Charlie
::Again? So here's the thing. Then we'll talk value, but buy it again. If chapter three comes out, I'm gonna get it.
Sean
::Yeah, for sure.
Charlie
::Right? I'm absolutely gonna get it. The other thing, keep in mind, it's an $80 bottle, I think, unless it is something that is radically different. Right.
They. It's a, you know, chapter three is a rye or something. Then maybe I'll think about it. If. If they take the same approach where this is an unfinished.
Which. Keep in mind, this is Penelope we're talking about. You would think.
Sean
::MGP,
Charlie
::But you would think the Penelope line. If they're going to put something out, it's going to be finished.
Sean
::Yeah.
Charlie
::The fact that they did the old switcheroo.
Sean
::I think they're going to continue with the switcheroo.
Charlie
::I hope so.
Sean
::Yeah, I.
Charlie
::Hope so. Because.
Sean
::People guessing.
Charlie
::Even as much as I'm talking about this, like, ah, kind of falls short. The Cigar Sessions are probably my favorite Penelope bottles.
Sean
::Honest. We can get into that because. Right. I really liked Penelope. And then I had the other ones the other day. The diner, the 10.
Charlie
::Years. Yeah.
Sean
::It's just. Okay.
Charlie
::Yeah.
Sean
::Don't get me started with the 13. Right.
Charlie
::I know, I know,
Sean
::I know. Hot take.
Charlie
::But. But I would say out of all the other, you know, I'm okay never having. No,
Sean
::I'm okay. Havana or the Riviera? No, I'd.
Charlie
::Much rather keep them on the shelf. So for me, buy it again is. Yes. Do I need a backup of this one? No. Will I get chapter three? Yeah, yeah, absolutely.
Sean
::Me, I'm. I'm not buying it.
Charlie
::Yeah, right.
Sean
::I'm not. I'm an avid smoker or anything like that. I come over, you and I. We don't buy the same bottles ever. So, like, I'm happy to have it with you.
Have a cigar, have a pipe. No problem at all.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::Value.
Charlie
::Okay.
Sean
::For 80 bucks.
Charlie
::So it's a six year. It's a very interesting. I can't help but compare it to the other Penelope bottles.
Sean
::I know.
Charlie
::And I'm like, yeah, it's pretty good. So I'm saying yes as a cigar batch.
Sean
::Cigar batch only.
Charlie
::Outside of that, like, if we're just looking at price, the juice, I got a tough time. But as a cigar batch. Whiskey. Sure,
Sean
::Sure. Okay.
Charlie
::Gotta go with it for me.
Sean
::It's hard for me because I'm not the average smoker. Well,
Charlie
::I mean,
Sean
::We sit on your deck and we have a pipe. No problem. Sure.
Charlie
::Yeah.
Sean
::Val, it's. It's hard for me to give that value.
Charlie
::Yeah.
Sean
::Because I'm not reaching for a cigar blend.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::You and I like. Right again. For the people who don't know, Charlie and I, we never buy the same bottles.
Charlie
::Right, Right.
Sean
::So like, he gets something. I don't get that bottle unless it's like something like, damn, I need to have that. Sure. That's.
Charlie
::Rare. Yeah.
Sean
::So I will say value for me is a no.
Charlie
::Okay. Because.
Sean
::I have no reason to go out of my way for it.
But I trust your judgment in terms of especially moving forward, comparing 1, 2, and 3, when eventually that comes back out, I think that's a good thing to do. So. Sure.
Charlie
::Right. So four for you, five for me.
Sean
::Three, four for me. Yeah.
Charlie
::Okay. So. And it's just because of the value,
Sean
::Correct? Right. Yeah.
Charlie
::Because we were the same on everything else.
Sean
::Yeah, we're the same on everything else.
Charlie
::I think now that we're talking about it, bottle two might sway me.
Sean
::I think bottle two is going to sway a lot of people.
Charlie
::But before we get to bottle two, if you're listening to us right now, which. How else would you hear this? Come.
Sean
::On, guys.
Charlie
::Make sure you subscribe. You. You follow whatever platform you're on. Just click that button so that you know, every time we put out a new episode,
Sean
::Whether you like it, you don't like it, let us know your review. It's fine. It's.
Charlie
::Fine. Leave a review.
Sean
::Leave a review.
Charlie
::Comment. Let.
Sean
::Us know.
Charlie
::What you.
Sean
::Think. Yeah,
Charlie
::Share it with your bourbon drinking friends or your friends that you want to drink bourbon.
Sean
::Oh, I like that. Who do you want to drink bourbon with? Guys, come on,
Charlie
::Send them the podcast.
Sean
::Let's do it.
Charlie
::Bottle two.
Sean
::Bottle two. The Wheel Horse Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey finished in port, cognac, sherry and Armagnac. Casks. Aged five years. Right.
With a mash bill of 70 corn, 21 rye. So it's a high rye and 9% malted barley.
Charlie
::And 101 proof. $40, 40 bucks. Now this is. Here's the thing with Wheel Horse. The cask strength came into my life and it was a bit of a game changer for the price.
Sean
::Yes.
Charlie
::Because that Wheel Horse really is like a Stagg Jr. Junior. Right. Like so now when we. We saw that they had a cigar blend, it was a. Absolutely. It's a.
Sean
::No.
Charlie
::Brainer to have it. Right. And. And the thing. We'll talk about this with the, with the Magnus as well.
But what gets me Most is it's $40 101 proof and you have all those extra barrels. That is not cheap.
Sean
::No, it's.
Charlie
::Say what you want about finishing covering up bad whiskey. It's still not cheap.
Sean
::It's usually double the price. It's usually 80 to again, 200, depending on what it is. That nose is incredible. Right. So.
Charlie
::Let's get right into the first impression.
Sean
::Getting right into it,
Charlie
::Guys. First impressions. Nose.
Sean
::It is so. Oh, my gosh.
Charlie
::Phenomenal. Buttery,
Sean
::Buttery. You get some, you get some fruit notes in there. You get literally like the cognac, you get the sherry. It's all blended. So. Right.
Charlie
::It's like you're in a, like a cocktail bar. Cocktail lounge. Right. Someone's mixing. You're right. By the. Right. By the bartender.
Sean
::Yes.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::Little potpourri.
Charlie
::Sure, sure.
Sean
::That's.
Charlie
::It is again,
Sean
::Automatically compared again. This is finished versus unfinished.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::And it's all battery. You know, it's subjective. Sure. The.
Charlie
::But that, that.
Sean
::Is so good.
Charlie
::You're telling me you don't want to drink this right now? No, I want to drink it right now. Take a little sip. First impression. And then we'll carve.
Sean
::Back whipping the toilet. Yeah, yeah,
Charlie
::Absolutely.
Sean
::But Wheel Horse is.
Charlie
::Yeah.
Sean
::Because this is sourced. So this is in Owensboro, Kentucky. So.
Charlie
::Green.
Sean
::River. Yes. So this is Green River.
Charlie
::Yeah. First impression. One word. It's delicious. Absolutely delicious.
Sean
::On its own.
Charlie
::Right?
Sean
::Is delicious.
Charlie
::And that is.
Sean
::You really get the malted. Oh, I'll get into it. But.
Charlie
::Yeah. Right, you do. So first impressions. Smells fantastic. And it tastes. It's delicious.
Sean
::You know what that reminds me of? The Chattanooga.
Charlie
::Sure.
Sean
::So the new Chattanooga finish and ice wine cask from Seelbach's. It reminds me that the finish, that malted barley finish and that, you know, the ice wine that.
Charlie
::Yeah. Combination of the ice wine finish with the malted barley.
Sean
::It really like that really reminds me. That's really nice,
Charlie
::Right? Really nice. So. So that's where we get into this now. If we think back, I know Joseph Magnus is up next.
When I got Joseph Magnus, I wasn't smoking a pipe.
Sean
::No. That was one of the first times I came here. Right. Not to knock on Wheel Horse right now, but going to Joseph Magnus right now is. I came.
I was a Blanton's guy.
And so when I had Joseph Magnus, when your bottles were less than a hundred, maybe 80 or 50, like you gave me Joseph Magnus, like, holy crap, this is delicious. It gave me that wow factor of. This is one of my favorite new whiskeys.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::Without smoking in general. I was like, we were just. We were just sitting at your bar. I was like, this is insane. I've never had anything like this before. Right.
I. I'm really curious to see how. I.
Charlie
::Know.
Sean
::The Wheel Horse and the Magnus is $40 versus $200.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::Maybe 175. You can find it. So.
Charlie
::That's really natural. So that's the point for me with. So this is a cigar blend whiskey. We talked about finishing. Right? We. We typically.
It's assumed that when we say cigar batch, cigar finish, cigar blend, whatever, humidor blend. Right. There's some sort of finish tied with it. I think that this tastes fantastically on its. On its own.
And that was my first experience with a cigar blend. Anything was just drinking it on its own. So that's why I have a tough time.
Sean
::So you're saying the finish matters?
Charlie
::Well, I. The taste matters in the glass.
Sean
::Indeed.
Charlie
::Right. Because the bottles that I have, it's nice to know it's going to pair well with a pipe in my case. Pair well with a cigar. Right.
Sean
::And I did have a pipe with you. Right. And I. Even with the aromatics, I enjoyed this very, very much.
Charlie
::It hung in.
Sean
::Very nicely.
Charlie
::You were having an aromatic tobacco.
Sean
::CAO Cherry Bomb.
Charlie
::Yeah, yeah. And I think I had like the Peterson Deluxe Navy Rolls, which is a really. It's kind of intense.
You know, Perique and Virginia, it's a little funky, and it hung in there very well. We didn't even mention that before we did this. We tried all the cigar batches on their own. With the pipe. Yes,
Sean
::Right.
Charlie
::The only one, because we just got it was the. The new Penelope, because literally we just got it. We haven't had a chance together. Right. But.
But this was one that we liked on its own and we really liked with a pipe. Right.
Sean
::For fall.
Charlie
::Right, for.
Sean
::Fall. Because right now we're the Fall time, you know, what do you want in some. What is your take on a fall cigar blend versus a spring one?
Charlie
::Yeah, that's different. So I know I want to change tobaccos.
Sean
::Absolutely.
Charlie
::Right. I think in the spring the.
You want something a little bit brighter because maybe you're going to have lighter cigars, but something like the Wheel Horse. I think it always works.
Sean
::I think so. I.
Charlie
::Think it always works. It.
Sean
::Worked very well. And we were sitting on the porch, you were like,
Charlie
::Right,
Sean
::Core moment. This is. I'm like, damn. This is pretty.
Charlie
::Good. It's pretty good. It's.
Sean
::Pretty.
Charlie
::Good. Pretty good. So why don't we work into.
Sean
::Gorgeous nose. I gave it a two. I.
Charlie
::Gave it a two.
Sean
::I gave it two. It's really nice. It's a forty dollar bottle.
Charlie
::Forty,
Sean
::Dollar forty. Oh my God. It opened up even more.
Charlie
::Yeah. I will say this is definitely one of those whiskeys where there's so much going on. It's very difficult to pick out.
Sean
::No, it's very hard because right now, this,
Charlie
::After.
Sean
::Drinking a couple of sips,
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::I'm getting a lot of brown sugar. I'm getting that,
Charlie
::Yeah.
Sean
::That wine, I'm getting that.
Charlie
::It's very buttery. Mulled wine where you have,
Sean
::You.
Charlie
::Know, some citrus in there.
Sean
::It's very complex for 40 bottle.
Charlie
::Right. Apple, grape, some sort of red fruit. Right. What is that.
Sean
::One? Grape?
Charlie
::I don't know. But mulled wine on the nose,
Sean
::Ground apple. Yeah.
Charlie
::The palate, a lot of that translates.
Sean
::I. I gave it a three on the palate. That was for what? I.
Charlie
::Gave it a three. And I. And I think it's because all of that does translate.
Sean
::Very. It's actually.
Charlie
::Kind.
Sean
::Of crazy because when I first had it, I got a lot of malted barley on the palate and on the finish. Right now after three sips in. Sure. That malted barley has faded to such a light.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::It's very refreshing. Compared to like, wow. It's not wow. This is malted barley. Because that's when I said Chattanooga Ice Wine Cask.
Because right now from when I opened it to now. That's.
Charlie
::An American single malt.
Sean
::Yes, it's an American single. It's. It completely changed. So it goes very subtle. It molds so well just on its own. Right,
Charlie
::Right. I think we're both gonna say it gets a point for value, but the finish. That's why I have the question. This is where the proof to me shows up.
Sean
::101. Okay.
Charlie
::Very easy to drink. It does just kind of stop depending on where it Hits my tongue. That's what determines what is left over. You get no finish in the. In the chest.
Sean
::No. And I'm okay with that. But it still lingers. Now, I. I would give it a one for the finish.
Charlie
::I'll give.
Sean
::It a one. Okay. I give it a one. I think they're still going on.
Charlie
::Sure.
Sean
::I think automatically. We just gave a 40 bottle.
Charlie
::Yeah.
Sean
::Seven. Seven.
Charlie
::Out of ten. And I. Wait,
Sean
::Wait, wait, wait. Still better than Blanton's.
Charlie
::Much better than Blanton's.
Sean
::A 40 bottle of Wheel Horse.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::7 out of 10. Go get you some. Try it out. Like.
Charlie
::Right. And I think.
Sean
::And. Yes.
Charlie
::Would you buy it again? Absolutely. Absolutely. Not only would I buy it again. Anything else from Wheel Horse?
Sean
::Someone buying. And I know one of our liquor stores you can get. There's a lot of different variants.
Charlie
::Next one we'll probably get is the double Oak.
Sean
::Yes. And the regular 101 bourbon. Yeah. I'd.
Charlie
::Be happy to try.
Sean
::I'd be happy to try that, too. And again, anywhere between 35 to $40 for finished and unfinished.
Charlie
::Right. I.
Sean
::Know a lot of people see price point as like, this is not going to be good, but Wheel Horse has really done such a great job.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::Just in general. Right. The cask strength. I really want to try the double Oak. Yeah. Maybe we'll do a double Oak episode. Sure. Most.
Charlie
::Likely make that happen. Or is it not to?
Sean
::No, absolutely. So seven out of ten for five year. Four. It finished in four different, you know,
Charlie
::Crazy.
Sean
::It's still freaking delicious.
Charlie
::Right. And. And that's the. And I think that's where it comes from. Right. Port cognac, sherry, and Armagnac. So can I distinguish between those flavors myself?
Sean
::Sort of. Kind of.
Charlie
::It's a fruit.
Sean
::It's potpourri.
Charlie
::And the other thing, before we move on to the third pour, this, I think, is especially good for someone, again, who's. I want to try a bourbon. I don't want to spend a lot of money. I want something very flavorful. This is something I think is good to sit with.
Sean
::And even if they don't smoke.
Charlie
::Right, Right. Just.
Sean
::On its own.
Charlie
::Right now. We don't have cigars.
Sean
::No. We're just sitting.
Charlie
::And we. We're enjoying this.
Sean
::It's pretty dang good.
Charlie
::Right. So.
Sean
::I'd rather reach for that than a Blanton's.
Charlie
::Absolutely. Absolutely.
Sean
::Hot take. Sorry, guys. But that's.
Charlie
::What it is.
Sean
::It is. Oh. Because this is finished or like. You.
Charlie
::Know what, though, here's my point with. With that argument. Sure. It's still a 40 bottle versus an 80 bottle.
Sean
::Potentially 80 if you can find it.
Charlie
::Does it matter that it's finished?
Sean
::No, I don't think so at all. It just goes back to.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::What people say about church whiskey. I'm fine with it being the way that it is. I really. This opens like again, like you said. Cask strength Wheel Horse.
It makes me want to branch out more. Yeah. With their offerings. Which I appreciate.
Charlie
::Right. And I can. And this is Wheel Horse. I am happy to be a Wheel Horse evangelist. So.
Sean
::Absolutely. Yeah.
Charlie
::I want people to know about it.
Sean
::Me too.
Charlie
::Right. I think we had a similar experience with Copper & Cask.
Sean
::Copper & Cask is something.
Charlie
::Same sort of thing.
Sean
::There will be those listening. There will be a Part 2 cigar batch.
Charlie
::For.
Sean
::The spring.
Charlie
::Yeah.
Sean
::And little preview.
Charlie
::Yeah.
Sean
::The Copper & Cask.
Charlie
::20.
Sean
::Year. Yeah.
Charlie
::Or 21.
Sean
::21. 21 year. Something different, guys. Wild. Wild. However, we didn't choose that one because we didn't think for fall.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::That would be appropriate. That would be an excellent spring.
Charlie
::Right. Right.
Sean
::So just a little preview for what's coming up in the spring. Copper & Cask. Just in general. I.
Charlie
::I put them. Right.
Sean
::Yeah.
Charlie
::And like we want to tell people about it. It's double the.
Sean
::Freeze. It' the price sure.
Charlie
::Is.
Sean
::But it's. It's worth it.
Charlie
::Yeah.
Sean
::Same with Reveries. We. We got so many ries. So many Reveries. Love it. But moving forward. Yes. Wheel Horse. Love it. Great.
Charlie
::Yeah. 7 out of.
Sean
::10. 7 out of 10 recommend. But let's go to the OG okay.
Charlie
::So this is one.
Sean
::Even waiting on this one.
Charlie
::Couldn't wait. Every time I get to try get to drink this whiskey I find myself appreciating it more. It's like when I read reread the Great Gatsby. Sean. Depending.
Sean
::On if you reread. Last time I read it was in high school when I had to.
Charlie
::So I've probably. It's a short book. It's not difficult. You know. Not a long read.
Sean
::Sure.
Charlie
::But I've at least a dozen times.
Sean
::A dozen.
Charlie
::At least a dozen times.
Sean
::A dozen. Wow.
Charlie
::Yeah. At least a dozen.
Sean
::What leads you back to that?
Charlie
::So I come to a point in life where I'm reading. I. I'm. I'm reading for enjoyment. But I also want to see how I've changed as a reader.
Sean
::Okay.
Charlie
::Right. And it is a good. Because it also has to do with where I am in life. And there are certain. Certain characters throughout all of literature.
And then we'll get back to the whiskey. Certain characters where. When you read To Kill a Mockingbird. Right. As a, as a child. Atticus Finch is your parents age.
What happens when you're the same age as Atticus Finch and you realize that you would put down the dog that's foaming at the mouth?
Sean
::Charles, I wish I said to you I. I read To Kill a Mockingbird.
Charlie
::You're killing me.
Sean
::I know. A.
Charlie
::Little part of me just died inside. Anyway, the same way this bottle is one I like to return back to. Just kind of like. Is it still good? It's.
Sean
::Still good.
Charlie
::I don't know.
Sean
::Compared to the all the new offerings that. Right.
Charlie
::Because so much.
Sean
::When you gave that to me for the first time, I was like holy crap, this is excellent on its own. And I didn't have a cigar with it. I have a pipe with it. Right. It was just something so different. And so Wheel Horse was finished in four different.
Charlie
::This is three.
Sean
::Three.
Charlie
::So this is. We're talking about the Joseph Magnus cigar blend bourbon.
So this is it has an undisclosed mash bill because essentially whatever good whiskey they can get, that's what goes into it 11 to 18 years. Typically this is about a 200 bottle. Yes. Sometimes you see it just under. Sometimes I think the.
Sean
::Cheapest I've seen it for 175.
Charlie
::Right. This batch 349 is 113 proof. This is finished in cognac, Armagnac and sherry casks.
And we started off this conversation with what is a cigar batch whiskey. This is it.
Sean
::This is it. This.
Charlie
::Is it. This is the OG cigar batch. Nancy Fraley, I'm paraphrasing the story. Was hired by Joseph Magnus to essentially the estate to re.
Engineer or you know, a whiskey that had been, you know, defunct for however long. Did that. And then the next thing was she is studied in Armagnac and cognacs. And there's a term I forget talking about.
Almost like the umami flavors that go well that you look for in an Armagnac and a cognac that go well with cigars. She wanted to bring that to bourbon rather than.
Sean
::The pioneer for it. Right.
Charlie
::Rather than Nancy Fraley trying to like come up with the right mash bill per se. We have finishing. If Armagnac and cognac do that, let's put the whiskey in those barrels. Let's do the same thing until we get the combination right.
And the same thing with cherry. Right? Exactly. How? Who knows. But this to me.
Sean
::But there's no.
Charlie
::Is the cigar blend.
Sean
::It is. Cuz when you first on the nose it doesn't smell like cigar Blend.
Charlie
::No,
Sean
::No. That smells like just a really good bourbon.
Charlie
::So first impressions. It's also a $200 bottle. We'll keep that in mind while we're talking about. About this. Right. Looks fantastic in the glass.
It looks great before it goes in the glass. No, it.
Sean
::Does. No, absolutely.
Charlie
::It's very light.
Sean
::It's very light. But again, it's finished in.
Charlie
::Armagnac. Cognac. Sherry.
Sean
::Sherry, Right. Not getting the sherry right now at all.
Charlie
::You're not getting. I'm.
Sean
::Not getting really any of the Armagnac. I could call the same thing from the Wheel Horse, which was like a very in.
Charlie
::Your.
Sean
::Face. In your face profile. This is like. This just smells like an expensive bourbon.
Charlie
::Right. To me, the barrel influence is. Is whispering rather than shouting at you.
Sean
::There it is. Whispering.
Charlie
::Right. So again, this. Right off the bat, the experience is different in that this is something you want to spend a little bit of time.
Sean
::Well, I think that's the reason why, too. When he gave it to me for the first time, I was like, this is just a great sipper.
Charlie
::Right, Right. I'm not.
Sean
::Getting the aromatics. I'm not getting any of that.
Charlie
::Nose is very light. Let's take a look. Very light first impression, then we'll talk about it. Right?
Sean
::Yeah.
Charlie
::And there it is.
Sean
::Oh, wow.
Charlie
::Right? There it is.
Sean
::Bam. Punch.
Charlie
::So much.
Sean
::Oh, my God.
Charlie
::So much going on.
Sean
::The nose does not match that palate. That palate is exquisite.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::The sweetness and the sugar rush that I just got from that. Wow. It tastes older, too. It tastes. Tastes old.
Charlie
::It's got a really good mouth feel.
Sean
::Wow.
Charlie
::Very complex.
Sean
::Oh,
Charlie
::Right. And that. And that, you know, getting a little meta here. But I think that whispering of the barrel influence absolutely carries.
Sean
::Absolutely.
Charlie
::Where you have, like, echoes of these other barrels,
Sean
::It's still. It just lingers, Right? It's still there.
Charlie
::Keeps going. One sip is enough. No, because it keeps going.
Sean
::It just. Dang.
Charlie
::So. So now. So we're talking about cigars. Yes. Right. If we say, okay, this is the cigar batch, quintessential cigar batch, which I absolutely do agree.
Sean
::Right. Because we did have a pipe. We had a pipe with this. We had tobacco with this. And we did agree that this was very good.
Charlie
::However, definitely prefer it more on its own than with pipe, because I think some of that nuance is lost as soon as you introduce anything else. I. I'd almost go as far as saying having even food with this whiskey. It doesn't. It's a.
Sean
::Dessert whiskey.
Charlie
::It. It has to be appreciated on its own.
Sean
::100. It's.
Charlie
::And now the nose.
Sean
::Nose opened up a little bit more.
Charlie
::Sure.
Sean
::But not much.
Charlie
::Just enough.
Sean
::It's.
Charlie
::Just enough.
Sean
::I'll take. I think the nose is pretty lackluster to the palate.
Charlie
::Sure, sure. I'll give you that. But I think it. You know what I would say it pales in comparison to.
Sean
::Yes, but that's.
Charlie
::Because.
Sean
::The.
Charlie
::The palate is. So.
Sean
::That's a writer, and you pales in comparison.
Charlie
::I know. Yeah, I do. Okay.
Sean
::But.
Charlie
::But. Yeah. So. So again, so this is a cigar batch. Now, we just went through two other pours.
Do you think either one of them are a good representation of a cigar batch? If we say Joseph Magnus cigar blend, that is the cigar whiskey.
Sean
::Now, you're saying cigar that you were gonna sit there and you're gonna smoke it or just. I'm gonna drink it.
Charlie
::However it's in the glass, we're drinking it right now. How do they compare?
Sean
::It's. They're so different, man. Right. They're so different. A good way, you know.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::Wheel Horse was very aromatic. It was very. It was lighter. It was lighter body. It was. But the. The Joseph Magnus, man, that is memorable for me.
Charlie
::Sure.
Sean
::That is just quintessential, like.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::Dang. This is delicious. It's.
Charlie
::So. So I'll say. I think the Wheel Horse gets close to doing that thing.
Sean
::Close,
Charlie
::Close.
Sean
::The. The chapter two.
Charlie
::Something different. Doing something.
Sean
::Way different on its own.
Charlie
::Cigar. The Penelope Cigar Sessions, Chapter 2. Very different.
Sean
::Very. If I had to rank them.
Charlie
::Right,
Sean
::I would say I want the Joseph Magnus. Right. This is. It's dark. It's. It's kind of viscous in terms of. Like that. Just that.
Charlie
::Great mouth feel.
Sean
::Yeah. Wheel Horse is a solid second. But again, you got a 200 versus sure. How close are they? I really want to see in terms. Well,
Charlie
::So before we get into that, one more thing. We had another cigar batch down here, which was only a bourbon finish in Amburana. Now, it was the Big Dog.
Sean
::Oh, my God. French toast. Yeah.
Charlie
::Did not.
Sean
::No.
Charlie
::Finish that bottle.
Sean
::No, not at all. You dumped it.
Charlie
::Sure. Did.
Sean
::She dump that? It.
Charlie
::Was not good. Do you think that had any. Right. Calling itself a cigar batch?
Sean
::No,
Charlie
::No,
Sean
::Not at all.
Charlie
::No.
Sean
::It was more of a flavored whiskey than I would say in terms of a cigar.
Charlie
::Exactly. So. So.
Sean
::You're. You're now talking about flavor profile now.
Charlie
::Right? So,
Sean
::Yeah, I.
Charlie
::Think these are very. I think that the Joseph Magnus, it tastes like a premium older version of the Wheel Horse. But the Wheel Horse, it does the thing. It's complex.
When we talk about the barrel influence. It's got that fruit cocktail.
Sean
::Potpourri, but this really has that age statement. Barrel, like, that's delicious.
Charlie
::Right, Right. So it's tough, and it's good on its own. The only. Only thing, I do not think it holds up as well with a pipe.
Sean
::Okay.
Charlie
::Compared to in the glass. I would much rather have it.
Sean
::Right.
Charlie
::On its own.
Sean
::So I agree.
Charlie
::Sure.
Sean
::100%. That again, going back to. You gave this to me just on its own. Like, I just want to drink this.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::I haven't had this. I couldn't tell you how long.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::And it's still the same exact reaction.
Charlie
::Experience.
Sean
::The profile is so wonderful just on its own. So let's go. Let's talk about scores real quick.
Charlie
::Sure, sure.
Sean
::The nose.
Charlie
::Yeah.
Sean
::I'm stuck between a one and a two. I'm.
Charlie
::Stuck between a one and a.
Sean
::Two. It's. I feel like the nose is very lackluster. I. It smells like a bourbon. Yeah, it smells like.
And I'm like, I, I put down a one because it is just, like, I'm getting caramel, I'm getting sugar. Like, it's just. It's basic.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::It's not doing much. Right. However, if I'm looking at the palate, I give it a four.
Charlie
::Right. I thought.
Sean
::That it's. We've never given a nose to a palate ratio like this. Between a one and a four is insane.
Charlie
::Right. So that's the. To me, it's a four on the palate. Yeah, absolutely. The nose, I'm in the same spot because it's. It's nice, but you really have to.
You have.
Sean
::To search.
Charlie
::For your. Your.
Sean
::It's just smells like a bourbon. It smells a little older.
Charlie
::Yeah.
Sean
::So. But again, there's not much complexity,
Charlie
::I think. So what you get again, I think the palate blows it away so much. I can go to a two.
Sean
::Okay.
Charlie
::Just because it's not a three.
Sean
::No, it's not. No, no, no, no.
Charlie
::It's. It's not a three. And I think when we're talking about these two, the Wheel Horse was two. Now.
Sean
::I do. But again, it's. Again, this is four finish. This is three finished.
However, I thought the nose in the Wheel Horse is a lot more inviting than the Magnus, so that's why I'm giving it a one versus a two.
Charlie
::Right. Okay.
Sean
::I think that's appropriate.
Charlie
::Sure.
Sean
::All right.
Charlie
::I, I, I might be leading more towards two, but I'll give you a one.
Sean
::No, I mean, you do what you got to do.
Charlie
::Finish it has to be.
Sean
::A two. I gave.
Charlie
::It a two for the finish. It was.
Sean
::Delicious. Yeah, that thing just lingers on. Keep.
Charlie
::Going. Keeps going and going.
Sean
::And I gave it a one for value.
Charlie
::Okay.
Sean
::It's a hot take. But the thing is to around us in New Jersey, I'm seeing the price go down. Right. You have a 200 bottle.
That was originally, but I've seen it for like 175. Sure. And then I just saw it recently for like130.140. Right. The lowest I've ever seen it before.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::So that alone I was like, wow.
Charlie
::Yeah. When I. When I bought this, I believe I got a bit of a discount on it. I believe it was MSRP was like 225.
Sean
::Yeah. I think that for 200. Right.
Charlie
::Yeah. I think. Because I also bought the other. Another something.
Sean
::Yeah, yeah. Oh, the. The.
Charlie
::Regular. The regular one. Not.
Sean
::The Murray Hill Club. Yeah.
Charlie
::So. So here's the thing. 200, About 200. You know, it's 11 to 18. Let's say it's 11 years.
Sean
::Sure.
Charlie
::Right. There's a. There's a touch of 18 year old. $200 For an 11 year finished in three, you know, secondary barrels. I still give it a point for value.
Sean
::No, I do too,
Charlie
::Because I think even about $200.
Sean
::I could get you.
Charlie
::Yeah.
Sean
::We just got the Remus 11 year.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::That was 70 bucks for an 11 year.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::Just saying.
Charlie
::Well, that's. So here's the thing. Now think about it. The way the score is worked out, if value.
Sean
::Right. No, you.
Charlie
::Go, no, no, but you take that point away. These are both a seven.
Sean
::Yes. No, but the. The Magnus is above the Wheel Horse.
Charlie
::If you give it a point for value.
Sean
::Correct. I gave it an 8.
Charlie
::I give an 8.
Sean
::I gave it an 8.
Charlie
::And I would absolutely buy it again.
Sean
::100.
Charlie
::The only thing, because of the price, I don't have multiple batches on the shelf.
Sean
::No. So it does vary batch by batch, but the current batch was what the.
Charlie
::This is 349.
Sean
::Yeah. So this bottle number 73. So I'm.
Charlie
::It's probably about two years old.
Sean
::I'm curious to see if we found where it was like 130, 140.
Charlie
::You know what? Even. Yeah. I'll put it this way. Even at 225. Once this is done, I'm gonna get another one.
Sean
::Okay.
Charlie
::Wouldn't think twice about.
Sean
::It. Okay.
Charlie
::Happy to do. I'm just not gonna have four of them.
Sean
::Four of them. Like you have other ones.
Charlie
::Right. I'm not gonna do what I do with Stagg. Right. I'd like to do that, but yeah.
Sean
::Yeah, that's delicious. So a solid 8 out of 10.
Charlie
::8 out of 10.
Sean
::Nose. One really lackluster, but the palate and the finish is really where you get it. Buy again. Yes. Value 100. It was a one solid eight. So going back. Yeah.
So, Penelope, cigar batch session number two. We gave it four Wheel Horse cigar blend 101 five year. We gave a solid seven out of seven. 40 bucks. 40.
Charlie
::Bottle.
Sean
::So think about that. Seven out of ten for that. And then the OG Joseph Magnus cigar blend cigar batch. Eight out of ten.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::200 To 1. 175. 150. Whatever you want to find it for. It's crazy to see these two bottles side by side so close. 40 Versus that, and completely different profiles.
But both.
Charlie
::I don't think they're completely different.
Sean
::Well, I think this. The. The Wheel Horse is a lot more fruit forward, a little more lighter.
Charlie
::Sure.
Sean
::Versus this is more. The cigar batch for Joseph Magnus is like. It's darker. Right. It's more viscous, and it tastes much older.
Charlie
::Yeah.
Sean
::But again, very close. And.
Charlie
::It's five times the price.
Sean
::Literally five times the price.
Charlie
::So I would say the. For. For me out of these. I. You know, and this is why I was saying, like, I don't know if we can give a point for value to the Penelope.
I think I'm gonna take mine away because I had a five. I already.
Sean
::Put it. Yeah. I gave it a four. I.
Charlie
::Think I'm gonna drop down to a four just because we do have Wheel Horse.
Sean
::Yeah.
Charlie
::All right.
Sean
::And we do have other offerings that we're gonna do a part two for the spring for. So I'm curious to see how things align in that respect.
Charlie
::Right, Right. So this was. This was a great.
Sean
::That was fun. I. I enjoyed this one a lot more than I thought I would.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::Definitely. All completely different. Right. But again, it's subjective in nature. Like, sure, we do it with the pipe, do it with the cigar.
Let us know what you think, guys. Like, which one do you prefer? Is there something that we didn't talk about?
There's going to be a part two where we have other three different offerings in mind. Right. And I'm looking forward to March and April, so we'll see what happens.
Charlie
::And we might also have to do cigar slash pipe slash tobacco whiskeys that aren't actually labeled.
Sean
::Oh, just in general, what's good with the pipe?
Charlie
::What's good?
Sean
::Yeah. Just in general. Yeah. But yeah.
Charlie
::Good stuff. So this has been our cigar batch whiskey episode. I've been Charlie.
Sean
::I've been Sean.
Charlie
::Until next time,
Sean
::See ya.
