MGP 10 Year Review: Chapter One Out of the Shadows, The Reveries 10 Year Single Barrel, and Copper & Cask X | Battle of the 10-Year MGP Bourbons
Charlie and Sean review three 10-year MGP bourbons: MGP Chapter One: Out of the Shadows, The Reveries 10 Year Single Barrel, and Copper & Cask X.
What is MGP bourbon? It’s whiskey distilled by MGP in Lawrenceburg, Indiana, the contract distillery behind many of the sourced brands on your shelf. These three bottles share a distillery and an age statement, but they taste nothing alike. So is writing off sourced whiskey a mistake?
The Reveries 10 Year Single Barrel
A 110.2-proof single barrel bourbon distilled in Lawrenceburg, Indiana, picked by Brown Ninja for Forbes Liquors in Brick, New Jersey. It’s oak-forward and viscous, with maple syrup, brown sugar, and leather.
MGP Chapter One: Out of the Shadows
A limited-edition 10-year straight bourbon at 111 proof, aged in Rickhouse G and the first whiskey MGP has released under its own name. It brings flat cherry cola, vanilla, brown sugar, and a hint of mint.
Copper & Cask X
A barrel-proof blend of 45 MGP barrels aged 10 to 12 years, combining low-rye and high-rye bourbon aged in Indiana, Kentucky, and Rhode Island. It’s soft for its proof, with marzipan, vanilla, baking spice, and buttery pastry crust notes.
Plus: why gatekeeping sourced whiskey doesn’t hold up, and how this lineup compares to 10-year benchmarks like Eagle Rare, Russell’s Reserve 10 Year, Old Forester 1924, Michter’s 10 Year, and Jack Daniel’s 10 Year.
Follow 2 Guys 3 Pours so you never miss a new episode every Wednesday.
Transcript
Charlie
::Welcome back to the Two Guys Three Pours Bourbon podcast. I'm Charlie.
Sean
::I'm Sean.
Charlie
::And today we are talking about 10 year Bourbons.
Sean
::Specifically the battle of the 10 year MGP bourbons.
Charlie
::Yeah, yeah.
Sean
::That Midwest grain products. So we have a nice little lineup for us right here.
This is in the making right now because right now we see all of the, you know, the new products coming out. Copper & Cask, the MGP brand on top of what are other things that we have got going on here. But Charles, if you want to go to explain what we.
Charlie
::Have in front of us. So we do have three 10 year bourbons. First up is Reveries 10 year single barrel. We just got. We have the new MGP 10 year at the time of recording.
It's new.
Sean
::Yes.
Charlie
::Chapter.
Sean
::One.
Charlie
::Chapter One out of the.
Sean
::Shadows.
Charlie
::And we have the new Copper & Cask X their 10 year bourbon. Just so it turns out all of these are distilled in Lawrenceburg, Indiana. They are all from MGP and they may maybe a little bit of a spoiler.
We did try these before. Yeah, we did.
Sean
::Try them.
Charlie
::They taste different.
Sean
::They vary, right?
Charlie
::They taste different. So crazy. So not only is it timely that we got these all about the same time. Right. Within a few weeks of one another.
Opened them all at the same time, Tried them all at the same time. And we thought that it was very not just timely to have these three bottles but the fact that they are all 10 year MGP products.
Sean
::Yep.
Charlie
::And maybe we should put them in an episode. Right?
Sean
::Yes, we should.
Charlie
::So here we are.
Sean
::Here we are.
Charlie
::So first bottle. This is the Reveries. This is a 10 year single barrel. So this is a store pick. A Brown Ninja pick from Forbes Liquors in Brick.
Sean
::Yep.
Charlie
::So this is a single barrel. This is the only single barrel out of the three. The other two are both blends. Get into a little bit more of that later.
So we don't have the mash bill.
Sean
::No,
Charlie
::We do know it's MGP.
Sean
::It is MGP. We don't know the rickhouse. We don't know where that sort of thing.
Charlie
::And this was $120.
Sean
::Yes, it is. Right.
Charlie
::So when we get to value.
Sean
::Yes, that's going to be an interesting one for you. Cuz when you think 10 year Bourbons. I think Russell's 10.
Charlie
::Sure.
Sean
::Russell's 10 is probably the most widely known Eagle.
Charlie
::Rare.
Sean
::Eagle Rare. Oh yeah, you're right. Eagle Rare, Russell's 10. But Russell's 10 is the more, let's say affordable.
Charlie
::And you can find.
Sean
::$45, Maybe even less at this point in time. But every one of those are. They're different. So no 10 years are created equal. I see all the other ones that we have on the shelf here too. And like.
And I got an MGP 10 year as well. That is I think is incredible too. Stillman's Sonder out of Dancing Goat. Completely different than these. So.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::I'm really excited. Even though we tried these back to back with each other is going to be really interesting.
Charlie
::Yeah, I think so. So. So first one up here, we got the Reveries. Everything looks good in the glass.
Sean
::Very dark color.
Charlie
::Right. This might be. This might be the darkest. Right. It's pretty close if it's. If it's.
Sean
::That might be. Yeah. Yeah. They're all pretty, pretty close.
Charlie
::Pretty close. The. So Reveries have quite a few bottles. Reveries. Talk about that.
Why don't we do a quick little sniff and taste, get a first impression going and then we'll. We'll talk about Reveries and how that has gone thus far.
Sean
::It's become the new thing.
Charlie
::It's. It's turned into a thing for us.
Sean
::Nose is very approachable. It's dark.
Charlie
::Yeah. So this is the, the Reveries 10 year single.
Sean
::Barrels. And again, single barrels vary. So this one may vary compared to the other ones that you try. So. And the store pick on top of whatever else.
Charlie
::Right. And this is. I don't think we said 110. 110.2 proof.
Sean
::110 proof. No. Okay.
Charlie
::I get a little bit of ethanol in the.
Sean
::Ethanol. I have some tea, some oak.
Charlie
::Yeah, there is.
Sean
::Oak forward.
Charlie
::Yeah. There's definitely, definitely oaky. I think it smells older than a 10 year.
Sean
::You know what? I was just thinking that too.
Charlie
::I get like a, like an almond note on there.
Sean
::Oh, that color is. Actually looks.
Charlie
::Fantastic.
Sean
::Was.
Charlie
::It? Yeah, looks fantastic.
Sean
::You know you look at like you just said before, eagle.
Charlie
::Well, yeah,
Sean
::Eagle Rare and then Russell's. It's very light. Very.
Charlie
::Different.
Sean
::Yes. So.
Charlie
::Take. Take a little sip. See, see what we got. Yeah.
Sean
::It's actually, actually better than I thought. I actually remembered.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::The legs on that. A.
Charlie
::Lot of maple syrup on the palate.
Sean
::Very, very viscous. Very, very viscous. First time.
Charlie
::So, so, so Reveries down here at the basement bourbon bar started out. You know, I. And what's funny is I think folks that were really into Reveries had tried T8KE picks. I've never had a T8KE pick.
Sean
::I've never had a T8KE pick either. So.
Charlie
::Saw Reveries, heard it was getting some hype. Right. Folks were talking about single barrel, so on and so forth. I think the first one was the eight year. Right? Was the eight year.
Sean
::Was that a store pick?
Charlie
::So. So now there's. There's.
Sean
::Two eight years.
Charlie
::Yeah. The first one I got has a name. It doesn't have the. The store name. Okay. On it. Right. Because some of them are.
They have like, a different, like, batch name. Yeah. Of single barrels.
Sean
::Yeah. Because you have the one. I'm looking at them right now. One is from. Again, from Brown Ninja.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::And then I think the other one was just from Brick.
Charlie
::Right. Yeah. Right. So. Yeah. So went from having one bottle to now it's the two eight years. Two ten years. The deep. A raven and murder of crows.
Sean
::And Cthulhu.
Charlie
::Yeah, the deep. That's the deep.
Sean
::Oh, that is. That's right. He's in the back there.
Charlie
::So. And. And what was most. I like the vibe.
Sean
::Now. They got some cool.
Charlie
::They look great. I like the. The whole aesthetic. But I. I haven't had a single bottle of Reveries that I haven't liked.
Sean
::No.
Charlie
::And they've been very different.
Sean
::Some gave really latex.
Charlie
::That 10.
Sean
::The other 10 year was like a latex mask. And I was like, this is weird.
Charlie
::Love it.
Sean
::That was. That was a fresh crack. Yeah. And then we went back to it. Gone.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::So that is so weird. But again with this, when we opened it, try for the first time. No latex.
Charlie
::No. Didn't know what to expect.
Sean
::No, no. It was very oak forward, you said, Right?
Charlie
::Yeah. The initial. The.
Sean
::Initial.
Charlie
::The initial sip out of this I had with my dad. It was oak on oak. It, like, that's all too much. It was oak and spice. And when we. When.
When you got to try it and I had my second sip, it's like, okay, now I'm getting open up there more. The. The maple was really, really coming through that maple syrup note, bro. Brown sugar.
Sean
::It's a dessert that's like. That's a nice after dinner dessert pour.
Charlie
::Yeah.
Sean
::It's dark. It really is viscous. It's dark. A little effervescent back there.
Charlie
::And I. And I still think that the palate and the finish makes me feel like it's older.
Sean
::So. Yes. Right. So now we go into. Okay. MGP. Do you get the MGP, like, funk out of this one that you typically get?
Charlie
::No.
Sean
::So, like, Penelope products. Right, Right. So I had the Penelope 10 year state from 2025.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::Was a fan at first. Not really anymore.
Charlie
::Right,
Sean
::Right. But it kind of started off well. They had that MGP funk and then another Copper & Cask. We'll get to that later. But it was.
You can usually tell if it's an MGP, in my opinion. I can't tell this.
Charlie
::I don't think.
Sean
::I can't tell this.
Charlie
::I wouldn't be able to. And I think some of that. Some of that. That. It's almost like, even on the older Penelopes, you still get. It's almost like a crafty, Grainy.
Sean
::Yeah, it's grainy. A little artificial, whatever. That cherry. I don't know what.
Charlie
::I don't. But I don't get that here.
Sean
::No, not at all. No. This is. This is brown sugar. This is oak. This is maple syrup. The viscosity is there. Right. I really like it.
And the finish is long, the first two sips. Oh, yeah. Pretty long. Oh,
Charlie
::Yeah.
Sean
::It's actually better than I. What I remember. Shocking,
Charlie
::Right? Better than yesterday.
Sean
::That's what it was yesterday.
Charlie
::The. No, you're absolutely right. Absolutely right.
Sean
::So what are you getting on the nose there?
Charlie
::Well, there's. I think now that I've had a few sips. Right. Nose. I'm getting that maple syrup. I get on the. On the palate. Definitely getting oak right up front.
Sean
::I'm getting some sort of almost like cherry or like a slight. A light. A very light stone fruit.
Charlie
::Okay.
Sean
::But it's mainly the brown sugar caramel. The oak.
Charlie
::Yeah,
Sean
::But it's. It's. This is what I actually like in a nose. It's darker. It's complex. It makes me want to go back for more.
Charlie
::Sure, sure.
Sean
::So. Yeah, that's nice.
Charlie
::Yeah, there's. There's a real nice leather note to it. I like. I said I like it quite a bit. Very different than the other 10 year from Reveries. I think this is.
Sean
::Yeah. Well, that. That Reveries, a few months ago. Right.
Charlie
::It's been a little bit.
Sean
::And then we did the eight year.
Charlie
::Those. Those were able to do those.
Sean
::Those were pretty dang good.
Charlie
::Yeah.
Sean
::And then. Didn't we just make that kind of work? Well, I think we preferred the 8 year over the 10 year.
Charlie
::Yeah.
Sean
::Now I don't know.
Charlie
::I know. Now I don't know. Changing.
Sean
::That's changed a lot.
Charlie
::Yeah.
Sean
::So.
Charlie
::So let's. Why don't we. Anything I'll say about Reveries or this bottle before we go on to the scores and we'll just talk. No,
Sean
::Check them out if you haven't.
Charlie
::Yeah, definitely. Absolutely recommend. Absolutely recommend checking out Reveries.
Sean
::No, Absolutely.
Charlie
::So now for scores, though.
Sean
::Yeah.
Charlie
::What are you thinking for the nose? There's a lot here.
Sean
::So we go into. So out of three points, the nose, four points for a palate, two points for a finish, and one point for value. All 10 points. So out of.
Charlie
::For the nose. The.
Sean
::Nose. I'm giving it a solid two,
Charlie
::Too.
Sean
::It's nice. It's. I wouldn't say it's like there's. After the first sip, it hasn't evolved much.
Charlie
::From.
Sean
::There.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::So it's not changing. It's still like the same brown sugar. I'm still getting the caramel. I'm still getting the oak. It's pleasant, it's nice. It's sweet.
Charlie
::Yeah.
Sean
::But it's not evolving too. Too much. No,
Charlie
::I think it. I think it mellows. I would. I would add on. It's got decent amount of vanilla, too, on the nose. Maybe. Maybe almost like a.
Almost like a marshmallow, but I think that. Toasted.
Sean
::Yeah. That.
Charlie
::Oak note, it's. It's really, really strong. So I think if you like oak, if you like.
Sean
::Oakier bourbon, like, too much oak, and when you get to age, too, like, the higher the age, the more oak that you typically see in some products.
Charlie
::Sure, sure. Especially higher proof.
Sean
::Higher proof. Yeah.
Charlie
::You know, that'll. That'll come true. So I'm fine with it. I'm.
Sean
::Fine with the toe.
Charlie
::With it, too. If you would have said it was a three, I would have been fine with a. With a three as well. I would have. What about on the palate?
Sean
::It's pretty tasty.
Charlie
::It's really good. It's really. It's really good.
Sean
::I think it's a solid three on the palate. It coats it. It's viscous. Makes me come back for more. It's like what you get on the nose is what you get on the palate, but it kind of.
There's something else on there.
Charlie
::Yeah.
Sean
::I like the effervescent that's given.
Charlie
::Yeah. But.
Sean
::It's like. Given, like, almost like chard.
Charlie
::Sure. A little bit of barrel.
Sean
::On there in the back.
Charlie
::The barrel influence is apparent.
Sean
::Yes. There's.
Charlie
::A lot. There's a lot. Yeah. Decent amount of char. I don't think it gets. I don't think there's so much of that char note to where we're getting. No, no,
Sean
::No, no, no, no, no, no. Sort.
Charlie
::Of like. No, like. Like you would get from the OCD or the leather. No, it's not. No, not that. No,
Sean
::No, no, no.
Charlie
::But the barrel influence it's.
Sean
::Definitely there. If.
Charlie
::That's.
Sean
::What you like, go check it out. Absolutely.
Charlie
::So three on the palate. I'm a three, maybe a four.
Sean
::Oh,
Charlie
::I think it's really, really.
Sean
::It's really okay.
Charlie
::So.
Sean
::It's better than what we thought,
Charlie
::Right? That's crazy. So I. I'm between. I'm between a three and a four on the palate.
Sean
::I think a solid three.
Charlie
::Three.
Sean
::Yeah. It's oak, brown sugar, vanilla, caramel, some little leather there. The.
Charlie
::Only thing I would like, I think would make it a 4 then is just one more. Something really strong, whether strong fruit. No, strong.
Sean
::Something different from what we. Absolutely.
Charlie
::Something defining it. But. But this is a really, really.
Sean
::Solid pour right now. Better than yesterday,
Charlie
::Right? Right. Finish.
Sean
::Oh, finish. It lingers. It's definitely. Again, it's. I'm between a one and a two. It. The finish is there,
Charlie
::Right?
Sean
::It's very pleasant. It's like a medium long finish, I would say. It's.
Charlie
::So I get on the finish. I think it's everything. You get on the nose through the palate.
Sean
::Yes.
Charlie
::To the finish. It is very consistent.
And what I like, I, you know, I bring it up all the time that, like, I continue to taste it, but this is pretty subtle, you know, like, you feel like you've been drinking bourbon,
Sean
::Getting that oak influence on the back, maybe a little toasted, but it's mainly oak. Light oak. Like, light, light, mature oak there. And that brown sugar. Right.
Charlie
::More oak, less char. Brown sugar sticks around.
Sean
::Yeah, it's there. So I'm stuck between a one and a two.
Charlie
::I think it's a two. Okay. I think it's a two dot and not for the reasons I would normally give something.
Sean
::No, because it's like.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::Yeah.
Charlie
::The other thing I. I will say I like about this quite a bit is even though you got a lot of that spice, it's not sitting in your chest.
Sean
::The first pour, that's the only time I got it in my chest. But everything else has been pretty good.
Charlie
::Sure.
Sean
::All right, so two on the nose, three on the palate, two for the finish. Now it comes to. Now.
Charlie
::We get to value.
Sean
::$120.
Charlie
::$20.
Sean
::For 10 year single barrel store pick.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::Now, is that what the normal 10 year was when you got it, or was it like $10? So.
Charlie
::I think they're all single.
Sean
::Well, they're all.
Charlie
::But the.
Sean
::Store picks are usually more expensive.
Charlie
::Yeah, but they're all. They're all single. Cat. I'm like single barrel. Single barrels and single barrel. Right. My. My Thing is just that it's like, where do we put the value?
Right. This is one of those that in a blind, when you're just tasting the juice, I'm like, yeah, that's $100.
Sean
::Yeah.
Charlie
::One thing twice about it.
Sean
::Now.
Charlie
::Once you. Once you like the 10 year is almost a detriment to it because you start to compare it to other 10 years.
Sean
::I was literally just about to say, you know, we have Michter's 10 year, $250. Old Forester 10 year was 150. Yeah,
Charlie
::I think so. Yeah. 140, Something like that.
Sean
::Russell's 1045.
Charlie
::Right. But there is a clear difference between.
Sean
::Huge, your.
Charlie
::Eagle Rare, your Russell's and then your 19. What is it?
Sean
::1920. Yeah.
Charlie
::Or 1924 is a 10 year.
Sean
::Yeah. And.
Charlie
::Then the like the Michter's 10 there is a clear.
Sean
::Yeah.
Charlie
::Jump. Right. But if you're just looking at the specs on the bottle. Is.
Sean
::This all vibes?
Charlie
::The vibes.
Sean
::Only.
Charlie
::To me, this tastes like an old expensive.
Sean
::It does. It tastes older than a lot of the other products that we've had.
Charlie
::Right. All right. So that's the thing. So I don't know as far as a hundred and twenty dollar pick, you have to give it a point for value.
s more or just as much as the:Sean
::It's been a while for the Jack 10. It's.
Charlie
::Different.
Sean
::There. Maybe you have to do a blind.
Charlie
::Might have to. I don't think I. I'm okay with it.
Sean
::I'll give it the point for value. The.
Charlie
::Point for value. So.
Sean
::It's a f. That's solid. 8 out of 10.
Charlie
::8 out of 8.
Sean
::Out of 10. And if you asked me yesterday, it was not an 8 out of 10.
Charlie
::No. No.
Sean
::So first round, MGP. Reveries 10 year, single barrel, 8 out of 10. Starting off strong.
Charlie
::Yeah. Way to go Brown Ninja. Nice.
Sean
::Yeah. Thank you.
Charlie
::Great pick. Yeah. So. So that kind of sets. Sets the stage for what we're gonna. What we're gonna do. Sets the bar very high. Right. Starting out with an 8 out of 10.
But before we move on to our second bottle, if you're listening to us right now, whatever platform you're on, you can subscribe, you can like, you can review, you can, you can leave a comment.
Sean
::On Instagram, give us a shout out. If you like it, great. If you don't, that's fine. Let us know what you think. That's.
Charlie
::Fine. But don't miss an episode. We have a new episode every Wednesday. Subscribe. Give.
Sean
::Us a follow. Yeah, exactly.
Charlie
::Whatever you can do. Everything.
Sean
::Everything helps. Exactly. Like bourbon we're here for.
Charlie
::Or you want to like,
Sean
::What do you want? Yeah, right.
Charlie
::You want to have a.
Sean
::Dabble? A little Bourbon Curious. Yeah.
Charlie
::Bourbon Curious. That should have been the name of the podcast.
Sean
::Bourbon Curious. Yeah, we might have to do that.
Charlie
::Yeah. We will rebrand. All right. Anyway, speaking of MGP juice.
Sean
::Oh, Their first ever own.
Charlie
::Yeah.
Sean
::Brand product. MGP label on it.
Charlie
::MGP has been making whiskey for everyone practically.
Sean
::When I found out today. Well, a. This one. MGP 10 years. Chapter One. Out of the Shadows, out of the G rickhouse.
What I found to be actually insane is that one specific rickhouse is meant to hold 100,000 barrels of bourbon.
Charlie
::It's a lot of barrels.
Sean
::It's a lot of barrels to choose from. A.
Charlie
::Lot of barrels.
Sean
::And this is the bottle that we choose or they chose. And then again, I don't know what the Reveries or anything else where these things come from.
You have many of those, but like 100,000 barrels is like unfathomable today.
Charlie
::Right. And that's one.
Sean
::That's one rickhouse. I think they have four or five. There's.
Charlie
::Plenty. But they are distilling for almost everyone other than, you know, the big names that you know. And I think the two.
Two things about MGP, before we actually start to drink the. The whiskey here, the.
You know, there was a time and I say, like, I probably wasn't as cognizant about it when I first started to get into to bourbon. But, you know, being a. A sourced product,
Sean
::A lot of hate behind it.
Charlie
::Yeah. It's kind of a naughty.
Sean
::Yeah. Like, oh, how dare you.
Charlie
::Right, right.
Sean
::A lot of people are still kind of aversive to MGP.
Charlie
::There are plenty of folks that just. I don't want to buy anything sourced.
Sean
::You might want to reconsider.
Charlie
::I think you need to. And. And one of the best examples is Fiddler.
Sean
::ASW.
Charlie
::ASW. Fiddler.
Sean
::Fiddler. Fantastic.
Charlie
::Right? Because you could take Penelope Weeded. Yeah. And.
Sean
::Put Fiddler Pretty dang good.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::I think it's better than the Penelope we did.
Charlie
::Oh, yeah. There's a difference.
Sean
::There's a difference. But I think, you know, MGP over the years has definitely got a bad rap, but I think people are being more open to it.
Charlie
::I think this is when we. We start to talk about, like, Gatekeepers. And there's a bit of pretension as far as, you know, I don't want anything sourced. I say, why?
Sean
::Why not?
Charlie
::Why not give it a try,
Sean
::Still be made like.
Charlie
::And if it says on the bottle, distilled in Lawrenceburg, Indiana, who cares? Who.
Sean
::Cares? Does it taste good? Excellent. Does it make me want to come back for more? Right, Excellent.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::So I'm really curious again. Tried it yesterday.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::Let's see what happens. But this is their high rye.
Charlie
::Bourbon.
Sean
::So.
Charlie
::36%.
Sean
::Yeah. So 60 corn, 36 rye, 4% malted barley,
Charlie
::111 proof and coming in about 70 bucks.
Sean
::70 bucks for 10 year. Pretty dang good,
Charlie
::Right? It's great price point. That's a great.
Sean
::Price point.
Charlie
::Let's do some first impressions, then we'll. We'll talk a little bit more about it. Looks good. Glass.
Sean
::A little lighter than the. The Reveries 10.
Charlie
::Little bit.
Sean
::Little bit. But.
Charlie
::Nose is completely different,
Sean
::Man. That's.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::That's more fruit forward.
Charlie
::That's what I was saying the first time. Yeah,
Sean
::That's more fruit forward now.
Charlie
::All right. The first. First sip I had.
Sean
::Yesterday was not fruit forward for me at least. Right,
Charlie
::Right. The like cherry.
Sean
::Yeah, it's like a cherry.
Charlie
::Almost like a cherry cola sort of thing going on.
Sean
::Yeah, it's very. But other than that, the. It's mainly. Whoa, whoa, baby.
Charlie
::Yeah. Have to take a little sip there and.
Sean
::Yeah, no, but so far,
Charlie
::Looks great in the glass and. Yeah. Took a sip there.
Sean
::Yeah. Y. Yeah,
Charlie
::There it is. Some would say whoom.
Sean
::Whoa. For there.
Charlie
::It is.
Sean
::10 years, 70 bottle. It's very light up front. So comparing it to the Reveries 10 year, completely different profile. Right. Again, same MGP.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::But like completely different. This is light. It's giving me like some sweet tea on the front there. I.
Charlie
::Got a lot of cherry.
Sean
::A lot of.
Charlie
::It's like that, you know, off brand cherry cola sort of like a. Like a really flat.
Sean
::Yeah, no, I can see that for sure.
Charlie
::But you also had like soda was on ice for a little bit.
Sean
::Oh, it's just. Yeah. Lack the carbonation or you just left it out for a little while. So this is 111 proof.
Charlie
::111 proof. I don't think it drinks 111 proof.
Sean
::No.
Charlie
::Right. I think it's very approachable.
Sean
::Very approachable.
Charlie
::So. So, yeah. So MGP, they finally put their name on the bottle.
Sean
::It's about time. Good for.
Charlie
::Them. And. And I would be very interested to find out what inspired that decision to. To do it.
Sean
::Right.
Charlie
::Now. Right.
Sean
::Especially too did they just get bought out?
Charlie
::Yeah. Or.
Sean
::The name change.
Charlie
::So now we have change. The.
Sean
::Name is changing. So is it still going to be MGP? Is it going to be whatever the new. Well.
Charlie
::That's the. I think that's maybe it's the legacy thing. We got to put our.
Sean
::On something now. Yeah.
Charlie
::Or you need another product on the shelf to just.
Sean
::Well again we have one. Rickhouse was a hundred thousand barrels.
Charlie
::Right. Come out with a new product you can. Now this is going to be next to your Penelope line. You could.
Sean
::Yeah.
Charlie
::You know.
Sean
::I'm curious too if they're going to do any additional. Any finishes Double Oaks anything with their name on it. Right.
Charlie
::Well I think at the very least we might have saw on coming whiskey or Breaking Bourbon whatever the the rye. I think other.
Sean
::955 Rye. I.
Charlie
::Think that's you know the next product to be released. But I look we are not you know not not speak for you here but we are not part of that group of. We don't like MGP.
Sean
::No.
Charlie
::Or we're not fans of you know, non distilling producer.
Sean
::Right. No. Like if it's good whiskey, it's good whiskey and it's worth sharing. It's worth sharing a story and you know, just enjoying what's in the glass.
I don't care like who made it if it's good. But it's not, it's not overhyped. Like you get celebrity things that are overhyped and they wind up tasting like garbage. Right. In my opinion.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::But this one they're very proud to say hey, this is what we're doing. And it's like people like whoa. This was definitely an eye opener. I think this is going to sway a lot more people to be like okay, MGP. I see what you.
Even though they've been mass producing for X, Y and Z, they just now have their own name on it. So.
Charlie
::And I think too like we we were talking about before we got the bottle. If you're putting your name on the bottle for the first time first batch is gonna probably gonna come out swinging.
Sean
::Yeah.
Charlie
::And I, I think they absolutely did that here. They.
Sean
::Nailed.
Charlie
::It. Absolutely did that here. I think it's interesting. You know it's you know it's 10 year. It's a bourbon.
I would have thought they would have come out with the rye first.
Sean
::Well they're known for their rye.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::Yeah,
Charlie
::That's what I would have thought. However high rye bourbon.
Sean
::I'm not mad about it.
Charlie
::No. I'm very Happy with this, but the, the. We'll see how it goes.
And I think this, you know, at this point, we have to look and say, okay, this is a 70 bottle already.
Sean
::Already for value. Like,
Charlie
::I'm happy with the price.
Sean
::Happy with the backup of this.
Charlie
::Right? Yeah, this is definitely a buy. Get a.
Sean
::Backup. Absolutely.
Charlie
::And I think, and I think too, you know, proof point is different than the other 10 years we talked about right there. Like the Russell's and the Eagle Rare. But like now Eagle Rare, it's about the same price as this, Right. At least here,
Sean
::Completely different.
Charlie
::Right. If we can come across at MSRP, I think the last bottle of Eagle Rare I got was 70.
Sean
::Bucks, maybe.
Charlie
::59.99. Yeah, I said we were lucky. I think the last one I got was 70 out the door. So.
Sean
::Now there's something to be said about these different 10 years. And because again, Buffalo Trace, nothing bad about that, but I'm,
Charlie
::I would pick this up over Eagle Rare any,
Sean
::Any day of the week. Any day of the week. Now we're talking about 10 years, right? The sweet spot is this is 10 years considered to be like the sweet spot.
Charlie
::I mean, I think it's going to vary person to person. I. I like a good 10 year. I.
Sean
::Like a good 10 year. I like, I like 8 to 12 years, I think. But 10 year is like.
Charlie
::Yeah,
Sean
::It has a little more like, okay, what do you got behind it?
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::Usually anything above that is a little more expensive, but.
Charlie
::Maybe. Except for your Knob Creek.
Sean
::Yeah, there you go. Well, Knob Creek, 12. Yes. 75 bucks. So 12 year versus that. But again, different conversation.
Charlie
::Right?
Sean
::But.
Charlie
::Yeah, again, 70 bucks. But that's. I think that's much oakier.
Sean
::Yes.
Charlie
::Even. Even. Like we were talking about how much oak influence.
Sean
::Yeah, that's still.
Charlie
::Yeah, but, but yeah, this is, it's really good, man. Are.
Sean
::You getting a mint on the nose there? Like on the.
Charlie
::Maybe. Maybe at the very end. Almost like before you drank your. You brush your teeth before you went back to your melted ice Coke.
Sean
::There's something there. Like.
Charlie
::Something bright.
Sean
::Something bright. It's. There's definitely cherry. Like you said the cherry did. The flat cherry Soda Cola. Off brand.
Charlie
::Yeah,
Sean
::That's there.
Charlie
::Yeah. Maybe a little. Maybe a little mint to say the, you know, the toothpaste thing. That's. It's closer. Like a, like a cherry Coke Mojito.
Sort of like the mint. It's balanced. It's not, you know, there's that brightness there, but it's not too, it's not too green.
Sean
::No. It's a little bit tannic. The finish is not as long as I want to go push forward a little bit here. The finish is not as long as the Reveries 10 year.
Charlie
::Sure. It.
Sean
::Kind of tapers off.
Charlie
::Let's get into it. Let's break it down.
Sean
::Let's break it down then. I'm fine with it.
Charlie
::On the nose.
Sean
::Nose. I'm giving a solid two.
Charlie
::It's gotta be.
Sean
::I think it's a solid two. I like that. I'm a sucker for cherry cola notes. Yeah. Suck like. It's like that little.
Charlie
::Mini.
Sean
::Stag right there. I think it's a solid two on the nose. But what.
Charlie
::Do you think? What would make it a three for you.
Sean
::If it. It hasn't changed?
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::So.
Charlie
::It's been consistent. It's been.
Sean
::Consistent throughout. I'm getting a lot of ethanol still.
Charlie
::Still.
Sean
::But if it, like, evolved into, like, a little bit of, like, creme brulee or different type of floral note.
Charlie
::Yeah,
Sean
::I think the complexity would have. Yeah,
Charlie
::I would like either one more note or just more of this.
Sean
::More cherry.
Charlie
::More cherry. Right. Like, think about the spike on, like, the. E.H. Taylor. Like, it just, like,
Sean
::What, the barrel proof.
Charlie
::Yeah. You just get that, like, overwhelming. What.
Sean
::The end there. It was, like, insane, right? Yeah. And at first it wasn't.
Charlie
::Right, but so. So I don't know if it's a little bit more proof or what. Definitely.
Sean
::On more oak on, like. So the last sip.
Charlie
::Yeah. Yeah, I was.
Sean
::More. Yeah,
Charlie
::I'd like more to get it. I like the.
Sean
::More. Yeah, that's fine. But it's still fantastic.
Charlie
::What about the palate? This is pretty tasty.
Sean
::It's pretty tasty. Is it more? Is it tastier than the Reveries 10 year? It's.
Charlie
::Different.
Sean
::There's different. Exactly.
Charlie
::Very different. Not as much of an oak influence.
Sean
::No. I'm getting a ton of vanilla brown sugar right now.
Charlie
::A lot of vanilla. I think the. Maybe it's one of those. Not that I've had one, but one of those, like, dirty Mormon sodas. Is that what this tastes?
Sean
::Oh, I never had one of those. Right.
Charlie
::Where you had, like,
Sean
::Dirty soda. I've never had dirty soda.
Charlie
::Cream and sugar to your soda, right? That's what it is.
Sean
::Maybe. Yeah. Yeah. I.
Charlie
::Think that's what they add.
Sean
::All the different flavors to it. Yeah. I never. My wife.
Charlie
::Told me all about. That's what this is.
Sean
::Is this a little dirty soda? Dirty soda, dirty. That's batch.
Charlie
::Number.
Sean
::Two. Dirty soda,
Charlie
::Dirty soda. I'm not for it.
Sean
::Palate. I'm stuck between a 2 and a 3. I am.
Charlie
::Sure you want to score it high.
Sean
::I do want to. Because.
Charlie
::You really like.
Sean
::It. I do. I think I'll give it a three.
Charlie
::I really like it. I.
Sean
::Really like.
Charlie
::It. I think what I'm getting out of.
Sean
::Works. It's balanced,
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::It's. I want more, and it makes me want to.
I think for people who, like we said before, a little apprehensive about MGP, I think this is your great gateway into. Hey, this is what we can actually do of our own product, of our own name on it. If. I think it's fantastic.
Charlie
::Yeah. I think there's no reason not to try it. I would actually go as far as if for whatever reason. For whatever reason, you're averse to MGP.
Fine, leave it. I will buy it. Yeah,
Sean
::I'll buy it. Leave it on the shelves. I'll take it. Yeah.
Charlie
::Whatever else you want. Because this is really good.
Sean
::Yeah.
Charlie
::And, like, this is where, you know, we'll talk about the. Are we gonna buy it? I think we even passed over that. Clearly, we're gonna buy it. We're gonna.
Sean
::Buy it.
Charlie
::But it's like there's. I have no reason not to not only get the next thing that they put out, but look forward to.
Sean
::It. Yeah, exactly.
Charlie
::Right from this. So.
Sean
::Like you said, chapter one.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::Came out swinging. Solid two on the. On the nose, the palate, a solid three.
Charlie
::Yeah.
Sean
::Now comes the finish.
Charlie
::Finish. I. I think it's.
Sean
::A one. Exactly.
Charlie
::I think it's a little.
Sean
::Lackluster on there.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::It's. You know, it's not as long. It doesn't tape. It tapers off very quickly. It just gives me a little brown sugar notes and. Yeah, that's pretty much it.
Charlie
::Cherry hangs on. Sure. Hangs on. Gets slightly. Slightly medicinal.
Sean
::Yeah. Oh, slightly. Very.
Charlie
::You get some spice that quickly dissipates. The only thing I would say where.
If I was gonna push back or play devil's advocate a little bit here with the experience I'm expecting from this, the. The finish, it's not long, but, like, the spice characteristic feels like it's slightly higher proof.
Sean
::Yeah.
Charlie
::Everything else, though, I'm getting. It's almost. Not that I want it to be lower proof, but hear me out.
Sean
::Okay.
Charlie
::Like, I feel like if this was 90.
Sean
::Oh, bottled in bond.
Charlie
::100, It's crushable. And it is.
Sean
::I think that, like, you said, like, 98 to 100 right there. I think it's crushable to begin with. I.
Charlie
::Think it's an interesting. It's a.
Sean
::Very. Yeah, exactly. 111.
Charlie
::Because this, I would like to try it like 98, but also like 128.
Sean
::Cask strength version. Let's see. Listen. They are going to spew out who knows what if.
Charlie
::It happens, I'm there for it.
Sean
::I'm down.
Charlie
::Right. I.
Sean
::Will get it.
Charlie
::So finish. It's one.
Sean
::Sips. One value. Value is one.
Charlie
::Yeah.
Sean
::That's seventy bucks for a ten year. For a solid ten year buy again. Absolutely.
Charlie
::No doubt.
Sean
::Solid. Seven out of ten.
Charlie
::Seven out of ten.
Sean
::Yeah. Fine with that.
Charlie
::That's good. That's a really good score.
Sean
::Really good.
Charlie
::Really good score.
Sean
::The next one though, I really, I, I. So Copper & Cask,
Charlie
::Right?
Sean
::You, you start your story first.
Charlie
::Oh, man. So.
Sean
::You start.
Charlie
::Copper & Cask. I don't even remember why I just got it, but I came across a Copper & Cask and it was finished in rum barrels.
Sean
::There's your problem. Yeah,
Charlie
::But I didn't know, I didn't know that. And when I first got it opened it, took a sip, said, that's different. And then took another sip.
You know, sometimes later it's like, that's different. I don't like it. And then it just kind of sat there.
Sean
::Right.
Charlie
::And I didn't finish the bottle. I think just from having folks try it probably got through a third of the bottle.
Sean
::This is the sweetness that got to you.
Charlie
::It was just. Yeah, I didn't, it didn't do it.
Sean
::Rum finishes aren't.
Charlie
::No, I have not been.
Sean
::Rum and amburana is not the no. 2.
Charlie
::So unfortunately I wound up dumping it because I even shopped it around. Hey, does anybody want it? Nobody wanted it. And, and at that point I was done with cop.
Sean
::Yeah. And that was at the finished whiskey.
Charlie
::Right. And then I was done with it. And then we were out.
Sean
::Yeah, we went out bourbon hunting that store pick that we found.
Charlie
::Random store pick.
Sean
::It was hot.
Charlie
::Yeah, it was like.
Sean
::But it was like.
Charlie
::10:30, 11:00'. Clock,
Sean
::11:00 Clock in the morning. Like, all right. But.
Charlie
::It was super,
Sean
::Super hot. But it was good.
Charlie
::Surprisingly,
Sean
::Surprisingly good. So open up the eyes a little bit there for Copper & Cask. Based out of Rhode Island.
Charlie
::Change our perceptions.
Sean
::Indeed. And then.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::Now on Instagram we follow whiskey weather on there.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::When he did the batch 16. Right. Of that. And he gave it a really high score.
And I was like, dude, I remember seeing that out and about at one of our liquor stores that we always go to.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::So I was like 80 bucks or 75 to 80 bucks. I think it was for an 11 year.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::Thing was unbelievable.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::That was what changed batch 16 of Copper & Cask now. Changed our whole perception.
Charlie
::Absolutely.
Sean
::Of them.
Charlie
::Absolutely. And that was when, remember I tried it against the.
Sean
::The Elijah.
Charlie
::Craig.
Sean
::15. And you chose the. Oh.
Charlie
::Yeah,
Sean
::Yeah. Over the. Gave you Kmart vibes, right? Yeah.
Charlie
::Any day of the week. And I was like, this is. This is stunning. But it really did change our perception.
Sean
::Exactly. It just takes that one bottle, one to two bottles. The one, the first one, like. Okay, dab a little bit again, it wasn't finished, but no, those.
And then you.
Charlie
::Yourself.
Sean
::Fast forward, you bought yourself another Copper & Cask.
Charlie
::The cigar batch. 21.
Sean
::21 Year.
Charlie
::That's wild.
Sean
::Stay tuned for that for one day.
Charlie
::Oh my. Burning tires.
Sean
::Burning tires and Welch's grape juice. Wonderful. Insane actually. Wonderful. But so this one, this is their new annual release. So this is going to be, you know, next year.
So this is their first, you know that. So from 45. 45 Barrels, 10 years, three months. But this is their double, right? They're double,
Charlie
::Yeah. So this. So this is MGP again, right? 10 To 12. 12 years. On the.
On the website says:So I don't know how the barrel split happened, but this was aged in Indiana, Kentucky and Rhode Island.
Sean
::Yeah. So.
Charlie
::Right. And then all blended together. So really interesting bottle.
Sean
::Very.
Charlie
::Right for specs. Very interesting. And again, it's $70. And.
Sean
::What's the proof point on this.
Charlie
::Is 116 points of this.
Sean
::The highest.
Charlie
::Right. That's why this one is last. But Copper & Cask X.
Sean
::Oh.
Charlie
::Yeah.
Sean
::On that nose you would think it'd be a more ethanol forward. It's not.
Charlie
::Especially. And again, this is the. We. We almost always drink low to high proof.
Sean
::Yeah.
Charlie
::Right. We always have a pour before we start. I don't think this smells like it's 116.
Sean
::No, not at. Not at all.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::It looks great. Looks.
Charlie
::Great. It's that.
Sean
::Dark amber color. Kind of comparable to Reveries.
Charlie
::Yeah, just about. This is definitely more amber.
Sean
::Yeah, that's all three of these look great by the way. For a ten year. Absolutely.
Charlie
::I'm getting some. Depending on how it hits my nose. Getting some ethanol.
Sean
::Yeah, but not as, not as much as the MGP for me.
Charlie
::No, no,
Sean
::The the regular, the brand. Chapter One.
Charlie
::Right, right, right.
Sean
::A lot of. A lot of vanilla.
Charlie
::A lot of vanilla. It's got that almond thing. Yeah. You know, we always talk about, like, what's that other thing? I think it's marzipan.
Sean
::Marzipan.
Charlie
::I think that's what it is. It's.
Sean
::That like an apricot, like a.
Charlie
::Orange.
Sean
::Is it? I don't even know what marzipan is.
Charlie
::Yeah, you got those little marzipan guys and you know, they like make little creatures and. And things. I'll show you. Yeah,
Sean
::It's a. No idea. Like.
Charlie
::A bakery thing. Okay, I'll show you. But. But there's what. I think that is.
Sean
::A lot of. There's a lot of baking spice on this too.
Charlie
::Yeah, yeah.
Sean
::But whatever marzipan is,
Charlie
::This is bakery vibes.
Sean
::This is. Yes. Okay. This is the biscotti. This is the. Yeah, this is your almond biscotti.
Charlie
::Right. Kind of buttery.
Sean
::Buttery. Not amaretto by any means, but like the. But this is cookie. This is bakery. Bakery whiskey.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::There you go.
Charlie
::Right. And. And I think one of the things we've. We've talked about all these, you know, a little bit of ethanol here and there. Sure.
But they've all been relatively approachable and inviting. Right. What we would normally say is inviting. Great viscosity. Legs. Legs. Legs.
Sean
::For days, man.
Charlie
::Right. Yeah.
Sean
::So.
Charlie
::What you just took. Yeah.
Sean
::That drinks 116 proof that that gives a nice warm hug.
Charlie
::Yeah.
Sean
::That.
Charlie
::It settles into the.
Sean
::Settle.
Charlie
::It's soft up front.
Sean
::I was literally just about to say it's very soft. Almost like a sweet. Almost tea up front. Sure. For me.
Charlie
::Sure. Yeah.
Sean
::But then. Yeah, the palate,
Charlie
::There's a little bit. There's a little bit of heat on the back, but I think second sip, it's going to be gone.
Sean
::Is that. What am I thinking of?
Charlie
::It's definitely marzipan.
Sean
::Sure. I was out shopping today and they were.
Charlie
::Marzipan aisle.
Sean
::No, it's actually funny. Mulberries.
Charlie
::Sure.
Sean
::This is a mulberry.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::Dried up organic mulberries here right at the checkout line. TJ Maxx, Someone like mulberries, Right. Is this mulberry? I don't know.
Charlie
::Maybe.
Sean
::Shout out the mulberry.
Charlie
::But this is. This is definitely the buttery, flaky crust.
Sean
::Yeah.
Charlie
::The almond cookie,
Sean
::Very long finish. It's. It's still going.
Charlie
::Right, Right. So. So I think that, you know, one of the other. Now that we're on our third pour here. Three different 10 years.
Sean
::Three different profiles.
Charlie
::From MGP.
Sean
::From MGP.
Charlie
::Right. Presumably the Reveries is either the high or low rye mash.
Sean
::Don't know. We.
Charlie
::Don't.
Sean
::We'll find out. Maybe.
Charlie
::I would say it's probably the low rye, just based on how it tasted.
Sean
::Yeah. So I'm not kidding.
Charlie
::No. But. But the Copper & Cask is a mix of the two. Right.
Like, again, these all came out about the same time because the store pick is relatively new as well. Yeah. So presumably the. The whiskey hit the barrel around the same.
Sean
::Time.
Charlie
::For all three of these should.
Sean
::Be at least.
Charlie
::Right, Right. Right about the same time. These are. These are very different.
Sean
::Very different. Again, same rickhouse. Different rickhouse. Higher, lower, I don't know.
Charlie
::All makes a difference.
Sean
::It does. And that's what they're doing is they're doing something really nice. You would think.
Charlie
::Yeah.
Sean
::I would just say, like, there would be very similar profiles.
Charlie
::Right. But that is why I think this goes back to the.
Sean
::Yeah.
Charlie
::The pretension.
Sean
::For sure. And.
Charlie
::The gatekeepers. You are telling me right now, you can look at these three bottles that are all 10 years, all from MGP and say, I don't like MGP.
They all taste completely different.
Sean
::Completely.
Charlie
::You don't know.
Sean
::We got. I got another MGP 10 year. That is sure.
Charlie
::Unreal too. That is.
Sean
::Literally not. No. The Stillman's Sonder.
Charlie
::Oh, yeah. That.
Sean
::Is like a completely different profile than all of these. So they are doing some crazy stuff.
Charlie
::But to say I don't like it. GP.
Sean
::Doesn't make sense.
Charlie
::Say I don't like sourced whiskey. I'm not buying it. I'm not buying it. Not okay with that.
Sean
::No. You. They're doing something really cool and obviously the product is good enough for other people to source too.
Charlie
::Sure. Because there are options.
Sean
::Yes.
Charlie
::They're the only game in town.
Sean
::No, no, they're not. But I think. What are you gonna. So let's break it down a little bit.
Charlie
::Yeah, sure.
Sean
::So get.
Charlie
::Some scores.
Sean
::I'm giving a two on the nose.
Charlie
::Another two on the nose. I'm.
Sean
::Giving another two.
Charlie
::Throwing out twos.
Sean
::Throwing out twos.
Charlie
::So. So let me. So we've had very different notes for all three of these. Why do you think they're all getting.
Sean
::I think they. What they do. They do it well. It's what you. What you smell is what you get. It's not really evolving.
Charlie
::They're all very balanced.
Sean
::Yes, they're exactly.
Charlie
::So do we not like balanced whiskeys.
Sean
::Or.
Charlie
::Are we just okay with balanced whiskeys? That's why none of them get A three.
Sean
::Yeah,
Charlie
::That's.
Sean
::Fine.
Charlie
::I think that. I mean. I think so.
Sean
::That. I mean, it's balanced. It's fine.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::But it's not. It's not moving forward.
Charlie
::Nice. Right.
Sean
::Like you said, it's balanced.
Charlie
::Yeah, I'm perfectly fine with the two as well on the nose, because I think, like you said, what it's doing, it's doing very well. I think it's very inviting. Slight change from the first sip to now. There's not a ton of complexity. I do think this one might be the most complex.
Right, okay. Or the most layered out of the three.
Sean
::Okay.
Charlie
::However, those light, like, you have to really search.
Sean
::You.
Charlie
::Where it's like. Like, it's easy to say, okay. You know, it's. It's a pastry sort of thing. And stop there. But I think if you.
If you're thinking yourself, like buttery pastry crust, you can find it.
Sean
::You can find that.
Charlie
::That vanilla almond note. You can find it. Right, right. Like, you just have to search for it. Right. But nothing jumps out. And I think that's why it's a two.
Sean
::Well, after you just said everything, too. Like, personally, I'm giving the palate of two.
Charlie
::Two.
Sean
::Yeah,
Charlie
::Yeah.
Sean
::Like, it's balanced. It's fine.
Charlie
::Yeah.
Sean
::That vanilla slight almond note is there. It's soft up front, goes in little tannic, little effervescent on the back there. But that's all I'm really getting out of it.
Charlie
::Yeah. And it's not as. I don't think it's as coating.
Sean
::It's not as co. It's not as viscous as, again, Reveries was very definitely.
Charlie
::The most.
Sean
::The most. Absolutely. And even the MGP, I think, had a little more. I think it was, again, it's personal preference at this point. Sure, sure. Like, the.
The cherry cola is very good, but when it comes to this, it's giving me, you know, it's baking spice. It's giving me the. The almond, the cookie. It's. It's good, but it's. It's.
Charlie
::Middle of the road.
Sean
::Yeah, exactly.
Charlie
::I'm fine with two on the.
Sean
::Pal. Okay.
Charlie
::Fine with two on the palate. Because I think the same thing. Nothing is really jumping out.
Sean
::No, it's.
Charlie
::But it. But it is.
Sean
::It's good.
Charlie
::Very balanced.
Sean
::Yes,
Charlie
::Very, very.
Sean
::Yes.
Charlie
::Very approachable. Very drinkable. I think if we sat and spent a lot of time with it, we'd get a little more out of it.
Sean
::Yeah.
Charlie
::But the other thing to keep in mind, we. That's the third. The.
Sean
::Third. 116 proof, too.
Charlie
::It did have the Reveries first. I think if you pull this off of the shelf tomorrow, it's. Damn. That's a good.
Sean
::Yeah, it's very.
Charlie
::Good. One thing twice about it. So the finish. So the finish. What it's doing. That initial hug is gone now after. Oh, it.
Sean
::Kept going for me. It just.
Charlie
::Still.
Sean
::Kept going for me.
Charlie
::Yeah, see, I'm not.
Sean
::You're not getting that. It just. It kept going.
Charlie
::Me. It's settled nicely The. The finish for me. It's. It's. It's there. I feel like I've been drinking whiskey.
Sean
::It's a solid one.
Charlie
::It's just. It's not.
Sean
::It's not. No, it's. There's nothing more going on. I'll give it a one.
Charlie
::Right. And I think again, it's also getting these scores because of the whiskeys we had right before it.
Sean
::Yeah, I guess so.
Charlie
::I think so.
Sean
::Even though we go from low proof to high proof, so maybe.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::We don't. I.
Charlie
::Think we just mix it up and see what happens.
Sean
::See what happens. Next one. Let's do it. Why not?
Charlie
::Right? Mix it up, see what happens. Okay. Value. It gets.
Sean
::100 For 70 bucks. You have to. Yes.
Charlie
::And we didn't even talk about how great the bottle looks.
Sean
::It looks awesome.
Charlie
::Beautiful.
Sean
::X on it.
Charlie
::Nice gold. So.
Sean
::So the 10 years. 70. The 11 year was 80.
Charlie
::Sure.
Sean
::Sure. Like, yeah.
Charlie
::There was a big difference between those two bottles.
Sean
::Yeah. That's uncanny. Right? Yeah.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::All right. So.
Charlie
::Would you buy it again?
Sean
::Yeah, I probably would.
Charlie
::Would you get a backup?
Sean
::Backup? No. The reason being is this is going to be an annual release.
Charlie
::So.
Sean
::So it's not gonna be like this is a limited edition. This. That it's an annual release that we're gonna be doing.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::I. I personally don't feel the need to get a backup.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::Compared to the MGP Chapter One.
Charlie
::Right. Right.
Sean
::I think it's. No, I'm fine with just not getting it back.
Charlie
::I'm looking forward to the next batch.
Sean
::For sure.
Charlie
::I have no problem getting anything that seems interesting from Copper & Cask.
Sean
::No, they're. They're fantastic. Absolutely.
Charlie
::Get it. Wouldn't think twice about it. I do hope. Remember we were talking about, like, the next batch? Is it just older?
I kind of hope that's what happens with this. It's just like, oh, it's 11 now.
Sean
::Well, then what happened? Okay, let me Compare the other 11 years.
Charlie
::Yeah, but that. That's what I kind of hope happens.
Sean
::No, I. I agree wholeheartedly.
Charlie
::Right. More than Fine with that. You know, again, it's a very interesting lineup and I think this goes to show how different the experiences are here.
Sean
::Absolutely. When.
Charlie
::You're just buying on spec. Because it's a ten year MGP.
Sean
::Yes. Huge difference.
Charlie
::And this gets a six.
Sean
::This doesn't. Six, eight, seven, six.
Charlie
::Interesting.
Sean
::Very interesting. Because in the past, if people, people are listening, it's usually the flip flop. It usually goes.
Charlie
::Because we're normally enjoying the higher.
Sean
::Yeah.
Charlie
::And these. And to be fair though, these are all within, you know, six proof points.
Sean
::Yeah. But they're completely different. And I remember yesterday,
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::You said MGP was your favorite out of them and then all of a sudden, right. Oh crap, everybody's 10 year.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::Something to be said. MGP. You guys are doing great things. Right. Awesome. If you guys aren't into it, you should be. There's nothing wrong with.
Charlie
::Right.
Sean
::There are so many different offerings, so many different profiles. And.
Charlie
::You know what? And I think the same goes for like we're talking about MGP here, but the same goes for Green River or your O.Z. Tyler juice.
You know, you can get sourced products from Middle West from all these other like contract distillers. I. I think it is wrong to just write those products off because they're sourced.
Sean
::Yeah.
Charlie
::That is probably the biggest learning. Yeah. And I hope that was apparent.
Sean
::I hope so.
Charlie
::Because three very different pours on. Save for the fact that the Reveries is a single barrel compared to two. Right. You know, blends or a small batch, whatever you want to say.
Very different experiences.
Sean
::But it's all they were. All very plus,
Charlie
::Very good.
Sean
::And still better than blends.
Charlie
::Always. Always. So. So do a little recap.
Sean
::Yeah.
Charlie
::Reveries 10 year. This was the Brown Ninja pick from Forbes Liquor in Brick, New Jersey. Gets an eight out of ten.
Sean
::Yeah, solid eight.
Charlie
::Started out pretty good with this one. MGP. The new MGP. Ten year.
Sean
::Out of the Shadows.
Charlie
::Out of the Shadows. Seven out of ten. Yeah. And then the Copper & Cask X.
Sean
::Yeah. Six.
Charlie
::Out of ten.
Sean
::One. Six out of ten. All fantastic.
Charlie
::All great. Would recommend all. Yes,
Sean
::I recommend all of them. Yeah, absolutely.
Charlie
::And I think depending on. Depending on your preferences, there is a 10 year MGP for everybody.
Sean
::100%.
Charlie
::Yes. Right. So.
Sean
::Bomb forward. Great. The subtle sweetness, the floral notes. Give it a shot. Yeah.
Charlie
::Wonderful. Wonderful. So this has been our 10 year MGP episode. It's been the Two Guys Three Pours Bourbon podcast. I've been Charlie.
Sean
::I'm in. Sean.
Charlie
::Until next time.
Sean
::Take it easy.
